On September 10, 2025, NATO fighter jets intercepted and destroyed multiple Russian drones that had violated Polish airspace. This unprecedented incursion of unmanned Russian aircraft into the territory of a NATO member state since the start of the Russia-Ukraine war in February 2022, immediately raised the stakes of the conflict. Moscow denied targeting Poland, suggesting the drones veered off course unintentionally. However, several European leaders expressed belief that the incursion was deliberate.
Poland responded by invoking Article 4 of the NATO treaty – a significant move signaling a heightened sense of threat. This article explores the implications of Poland's action and potential future developments.
Article 4 allows any NATO member feeling threatened to request consultations within the North Atlantic Council (NAC), the alliance's highest political decision-making body. While NAC meetings are routine, Article 4 triggers a special session focused on determining the alliance's next steps. This differs from Article 5, the cornerstone of the NATO alliance, which mandates a collective response if one member is attacked.
The invocation of Article 4 is a serious matter, though it doesn't automatically lead to military action like Article 5. The latter, triggered only once before (after 9/11), commits all NATO members to defend an attacked ally. Even then, the response isn't predetermined; each member retains sovereignty and decides its course of action. The US, for example, would require presidential action, potentially involving Congressional input, before any direct military involvement.
Article 4 has been invoked previously, notably by Turkey regarding cross-border terrorism stemming from the Syrian War and by eight Eastern European NATO members following Russia's February 24th invasion of Ukraine. Poland's action, however, carries specific weight given the direct violation of its airspace.
The repeated incursions of Russian military forces into allied airspace along NATO's eastern border, particularly in northeastern Europe, have become increasingly concerning. While some incidents might be attributed to error, the frequency suggests a deliberate strategy by Russia, ranging from using circuitous routes to avoid Ukrainian defenses to intimidation tactics.
Poland's invocation of Article 4 aims to secure unequivocal allied backing for a more assertive response to these provocations. The US, viewing Poland as a key ally, is likely to offer strong support. Possible measures include enhanced air defenses, potentially involving the deployment of US assets like Patriot battalions currently based in Germany, although this remains unconfirmed. The situation highlights the escalating tensions and the complex challenges facing NATO in responding to Russia's actions in the region. The upcoming NAC meetings will be crucial in determining the collective response and shaping the future trajectory of the conflict.
---
Originally published at: https://theconversation.com/poland-responds-to-russian-drones-incursion-by-invoking-article-4-of-the-nato-treaty-what-happens-next-265051
