The Minnesota Vikings are facing a significant setback as starting quarterback J.J. McCarthy will miss Week 3 due to an ankle injury sustained during their Week 2 loss to the Atlanta Falcons. Veteran quarterback Carson Wentz will step in as the starter, marking a sudden shift in the team's dynamic.
Head coach Kevin O'Connell confirmed McCarthy's injury on Monday, emphasizing that the decision to sideline him was solely due to the injury, not performance. O'Connell expressed his disappointment, highlighting McCarthy's promising start to the season, which included a standout performance in his debut. The injury occurred in the third quarter when McCarthy scrambled, taking a hit that resulted in an ankle injury. Initially treated on the sidelines, the extent of the injury only became clear on Monday morning.
McCarthy's injury raises concerns, echoing a similar situation last year when he suffered a torn meniscus. While the severity of this ankle injury appears different, it highlights pre-draft concerns surrounding his durability. The injury also jeopardizes the team's plans for McCarthy to gain experience and refinement through scout team practice.
The Vikings' offensive line also presents a major concern. Center Ryan Kelly is currently in concussion protocol, and there are questions surrounding the availability of left tackle Christian Darrisaw. These uncertainties further complicate Wentz's task, adding pressure on a line that already showed significant weaknesses in Week 2. The Vikings’ offensive line is facing a major test against the Cincinnati Bengals' stellar pass rush, led by Trey Hendrickson, further adding to the team's challenges.
Wentz, signed recently, brings experience but also a history of inconsistent play. His arm strength is not a concern, but accuracy and decision-making have been questions throughout his career. O'Connell expressed confidence in Wentz's ability to lead the offense, highlighting his veteran presence and grasp of the playbook. While Wentz is a capable player, questions linger about his ability to consistently perform at a high level.
Adding to the Vikings’ woes is the injury to running back Aaron Jones who suffered a hamstring injury. The combination of injuries and offensive line instability creates a formidable challenge for the Vikings heading into Week 3 and beyond. The team's immediate and long-term prospects are now undeniably clouded by uncertainty, raising questions about their ability to overcome these significant hurdles.
---
Originally published at: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6631929/2025/09/15/jj-mccarthy-hurt-carson-wentz-vikings-depth-chart/
