Taylor Frankie Paul, a star from 'Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,' is the new Bachelorette, a decision sparking fervent debate among fans. This unconventional choice follows the less-than-stellar 21st season and a period of declining ratings for the long-running ABC franchise. Paul, with a substantial 1.7 million Instagram followers, brings a unique and controversial past to the role. Known for her #MomTok presence and a highly publicized, messy divorce involving 'soft-swinging' within the Mormon community, her story already boasts significant media attention.
Her relationship with Dakota Mortensen, another reality TV storyline, ended with an aggravated assault charge, resulting in a plea deal. This history has divided fans. While some celebrate the casting as a bold, potentially revitalizing move that will draw new viewers intrigued by the drama, others express concerns about glorifying a figure with a history of domestic violence. Several social media users voiced their apprehensions.
The network's decision is seen as a high-stakes gamble by reality TV experts. Emma Gray, co-host of the 'Love To See It' podcast, notes that ABC is taking a massive risk by choosing a lead with such a public, complicated history. Unlike previous leads chosen from within the franchise's existing pool of contestants, Paul's background is entirely different. Gray highlights that Paul's experience with public scrutiny might make her well-equipped to handle the intense media attention the show brings.
Paul herself has addressed past mistakes in interviews, expressing remorse and claiming to be in a better place. Gray suggests that the show's success hinges on its willingness to honestly address Paul's past and avoid sanitizing her story. Some see Paul’s controversial background as an opportunity to inject much-needed authenticity into a franchise often criticized for lacking genuine depth. Others fear that this approach could be the franchise's undoing.
Ultimately, ABC is betting on the controversy surrounding Paul to generate significant buzz and revitalize 'The Bachelorette.' Whether this risky strategy will succeed remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: the upcoming season promises to be anything but boring.
---
Originally published at: https://www.nbcnews.com/pop-culture/pop-culture-news/bachelorette-fans-say-taylor-frankie-paul-could-help-revive-franchise-rcna230361
